Recent Blog Posts
COVID-19 & Florida Theft Crimes
Although there has been an increase in domestic violence calls in Florida since the COVID-19 pandemic arrived in the United States, there has also been an increased in felony crimes, including theft crimes such as grand theft.
According to the Dothan Eagle, Jackson County law enforcement officials arrested and charged a Houston County juvenile with grand theft, grand theft of a firearm, and armed burglary of a dwelling after burglarizing a building with a stolen gun and tried to steal a vehicle to escape the scene. ABC7 reported on April 1 that the Manatee County Sheriff's Office was looking for a person or group of individuals accused of grand theft and burglary removing five RV trailers in Bradenton and stealing contents inside those trailers.
The coronavirus outbreak has forced many businesses to close its doors until further notice, which has also led to many people losing their jobs. These frightening and uncertain times, mixed with unemployment and the stress of supporting the family, can result in desperation, causing people to commit theft in order to stock up on essential items and survive.
Domestic Violence to Increase During Coronavirus Quarantine
Throughout Florida and across the United States, millions of Americans have started to quarantine themselves in their homes in hopes of hindering the spread of Coronavirus and flattening the curve of new cases each day. However, since people are now stuck in their homes 24 hours a day and seven days a week -- either because they were either mandated to work from home by their job or, unfortunately, laid off -- the National Domestic Violence Hotline and law enforcement officials in every state expect an increase of domestic violence incidents in the coming weeks or months.
In fact, several domestic violence reporting systems have experienced an increase in phone calls within the last week. Whether we are in the middle of a pandemic or not, unemployment, guns in the home, forced sex, and previous incidents of domestic violence often lead to domestic homicide.
According to Axios, when China instituted its quarantine mandate, the number of domestic violence cases reported to the police tripled in February in comparison to last year. Activists claim enforced lockdown led to the spike of such incidents.
How COVID-19 Affects Florida Criminal Courts
From work and school to concerts and sporting events, the Coronavirus outbreak has put a stop to many aspects of our daily lives. Federal, state, and local governments have issued mandates requiring most people to stay in their homes for at least two weeks in order to "flatten the curve" of new cases and deaths throughout the United States.
But what does that mean for people who are scheduled to appear in criminal courts? In Florida, many courthouses throughout the state have closed their doors for the time being.
On Tuesday, the Florida Supreme Court issued a statewide order, limiting how the court functions during the pandemic that will remain in effect until March 27. Chief Justice Charles Canady said that criminal and civil jury trials, grand jury proceedings, and jury selection proceedings have all been suspended.
On the same day, Miami-Dade County Courthouse shut down court facilities until March 27 as well. Staff members will work from until during this period.
Internet Solicitation in Florida
If you are convicted of Internet solicitation in Florida, you may be sentenced to prison. However, under certain circumstances, a defendant in a Miami sex crime case may be sentenced to sex offender probation. There are specific rules that must be followed when the court imposes a sentence in connection with sex offender probation. In a recent Florida case, the court considered whether the lower court must orally pronounce every term of sex offender probation set forth under Florida Statute section 948.30 in situations in which there isn't a conviction of an offense specified under the statute. The defendant had been charged under Florida Statute section 847.0135(3) with two counts of lewd computer solicitation of a child. He was also charged with traveling to meet a minor for illegal sexual activity.
He pled no contest and asked the court to depart downward when sentencing. Specifically, he hoped not to be sentenced to prison. Instead, he hoped to be put on sex offender probation with house arrest.
Exceptions to Right of Pretrial Release in Miami
Under the Florida Constitution, somebody arrested for a crime has the right to pretrial release on reasonable conditions like a bond, subject to specific exceptions under Article I, section 14. There is an exception that may apply if you're charged with a capital or life offense, ones that can be punished by life imprisonment or capital punishment, and the prosecutor is able to show that the proof of guilt is evident or that the presumption is great. If you're held under this exception, you are supposed to receive an adversarial, evidentiary bond hearing known as an Arthur hearing that looks at the prosecutor's proof to decide whether it rises to that level of proof, which is a standard stronger than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard. If you have been arrested for a crime, having a knowledgeable Miami criminal defense attorney review your case is crucial. In a recent Florida appellate case related to rights under Article I, section 14, the defendant, confined in Miami-Dade County jail, petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus.
Pretrial Detention Without Bond in Broward County First Appearances
If you're arrested, you're supposed to be taken before a judicial officer within 24 hours of arrest for a first appearance. Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.131(b) requires the court at a first appearance to decide pretrial release conditions for eligible defendants, except where the State has moved for pretrial detention.
In a recent Broward County criminal appeal involving consolidated proceedings, the petitioners argued that pretrial detention without bond was not appropriate. The defendants were charged with felonies punishable by life. At their first appearance, the court found there was probable cause to believe they'd committed the crimes with which they were charged. It refused to set bond without first deciding whether a probable cause affidavit established proof of guilt was clear or the presumption was great. The petitioners argued the refusal to set bond or make requisite findings violated Florida Constitution Article I, section 14.
In order to hold a defendant without bond before an Arthur hearing, a first appearance judge needs to find that the probable cause affidavit shows proof of guilt is evident or the presumption is great. The appellate court explained that at a first appearance, the court needed to make a finding of whether the probable cause affidavit or something else shown to the court established proof of guilt was clear or the presumption great as grounds to deny pretrial release without bond. When this very tough standard is met, and the court decides not to set bond, the defendant can later ask that the bond be set aside and ask for a full Arthur hearing. At a full Arthur hearing, a defendant can put forward evidence and ask the court to use its discretion to set bond.
Miami Sentencing Involving the Youthful Offender Act
The Youthful Offender Act was enacted to give lower courts sentencing alternatives for defendants who are under 21-years-old and meet certain eligibility criteria. If you meet these criteria in Miami, it may be possible to ask the court to sentence you as a youthful offender, and these penalties are less harsh than adult sentencing. A skillful Miami criminal defense attorney with knowledge of sentencing alternatives can help you make sense of your options. In a recent Florida case, an appellate court reconsidered an earlier ruling about its sentencing of a defendant previously deemed a youthful offender.
The case arose when a young man was charged with aggravated battery. His sentence was imposed pursuant to the Youthful Offender Act, which permits at most six years of incarceration for those treated as youthful offenders. Accordingly, the defendant's sentence involved 479 days in prison plus 18 months of community control and 18 months of probation. After the community control was revoked for a substantive violation, the lower court sentenced him to a mandatory minimum term of 20 years imprisonment under the 10-20-Life statute, section 775.087(2)(a).
Credit Card Fraud in Broward County
Broward County credit card fraud claims are taken seriously. Credit card fraud can be charged under federal or state laws. When charged as a state crime, it's known as fraudulent use of a credit card. In a Florida appellate case, the defendant was convicted of multiple charges including fraudulent use of a credit card that violated Florida Statutes section 817.61.
On appeal, he argued only the lower court made a mistake in denying his motion for judgment of acquittal with regard to fraudulent use of a credit card. He claimed that in using the stolen credit card, he didn't represent he was actually authorized to use it.
The case arose when the victim whose card was stolen was on retreat at a monastery when she got an alert her debit card had been used to charge something. The victim testified she didn't give anybody permission to use the card. She knew she hadn't made any charges and found her whole purse was missing. A monastery employee was told about the theft and said there'd been someone on the premises acting suspiciously and wearing a construction vest. The person tried to hide when he saw the employee.
Convicted Felon Carrying a Concealed Weapon in Florida
If you are a convicted felon in Miami, you are not allowed to carry a concealed weapon. In a recent appellate decision, the court considered an appeal from a conviction for possession of a concealed weapon by a convicted felon. If you are facing firearms charges, contact a Miami gun crime attorney as soon as possible.
The defendant raised several arguments on appeal. The first argument he raised was that a firearm was not a weapon under Florida Statutes section 790.001(3)(a) and therefore couldn't be treated as a concealed weapon. The appellate court explained that phrases have to be read within their context, not in isolation and law needs to be interpreted to provide the effect to every clause it contains so that there is harmony or meaning.
A concealed weapon under section 790.001 includes any firearm carried on or about someone so as to hide the firearm from ordinary sight. Firearms include any weapon that can be easily converted to send out a projectile or is designed to do so. It also includes the receiver or frame of that type of weapon. Weapons can include metallic knuckles, tear gas gun, dirk, chemical weapon or device or another deadly weapon carried on someone so as to hide the weapon from ordinary sight.
Aggravated Stalking Charges After a Domestic Violence Injunction is Ordered
If you are subject to an injunction related to domestic violence in Broward County, it's important to follow the rules established by the injunction. Typically, an injunction for domestic violence includes restraints on the defendant's communications with the victim. A domestic violence injunction may require you not to communicate at all with the victim, and to stay a certain distance away from her person, her home, her car, and her workplace. Failure to follow the mandate of the injunction can result in greater charges.
In a recent Florida appellate decision related to aggravated stalking, the court considered whether text messages to the victim could be impeachment evidence. There had been texts between the defendant and his wife, who was the victim of his stalking before a domestic violence injunction had been put in place.
When trial started the defendant and the government talked about whether the texts should be admitted. The lower court found that texts couldn't be admitted because the government had failed to file a timely notice to admit the texts as collateral crime evidence, but it found that they could be used as impeachment evidence by the defense or presented by the government during its rebuttal to the defense.